What is going on with Mass schools? Seems like the Head of the Dept of ED is
NOT on the job. You can also tell who the ones are creating the issues they are the ones who see no issues or problems , and
YES , it very much so affects the kids . This we have seen and will see more so in a few weeks .
Amherst-Pelham
Regional School Committee we have a Superintendent who will fit right in for you , gladly given. :) For that matter a SC who is just as useless.
Suspicion, mistrust and deception on the Amherst-Pelham
Regional School Committee, and its continued dysfunction, are cited by
Leverett representative Sarah Dolven in a resignation letter to the
nine-member panel.
In the email sent to her former colleagues Aug.
19, and released by school officials to the Gazette Wednesday, Sarah
Dolven wrote that “I felt I could no longer ethically continue
participating in the process” after resigning following the committee’s
Aug. 17 meeting.
Dolven, who rejoined the regional board in May
after a year in which Kip Fonsh served as Leverett’s representative,
added “I am truly heartsick at the level of dysfunction in this
committee, and the level of suspicion, mistrust and deception that is
apparent.”
Dolven wrote in her email that she regarded her return
to the regional committee as provisional because she was not sure she
could make the time commitment due to professional and family
obligations. Dolven also thanked her colleagues.
“I respect each
and every member of the committee and honor their commitment to serving
the school district, and I hope that somehow the committee and the
community can get back on track and work together to support our
schools,” she wrote.
Dolven continues as a member of the Leverett School Committee.
Her
resignation came a week after regional committee and the Union 26
School Committee agreed on a $309,238 payment to former superintendent
Maria Geryk to leave her position. The agreement was reached following
four executive sessions and the issuing of a demand letter in which
Geryk is alleged to have threatened legal action against the committee
and its members.
Amherst School Committee his Chairwoman Katherine
Appy said in an email Wednesday that she shares Dolven’s view that
there is dysfunction on the regional committee.
“In response to
her comments, I agree that the committee has been dysfunctional and I
too hope that the community will rally in support of the schools,” Appy
said.
But Appy said that she is “very sad” Dolven chose to depart from the regional committee’s work.
“She was an intelligent voice of reason on our committee,” Appy said.
Differing views Vira Douangmany Cage, another elected Amherst representative, said she is not sure that dysfunction is the right term.
”Disagreement
is not dysfunction, challenging is not dysfunction,” she said. “Part of
our democracy is to have differing opinions.”
Being elected to a school committees carries more responsibilities than being on a parent-teacher group, she said.
“It’s
a very serious issue, a very serious job and we should come prepared to
handle a lot of pressure and stress,” Douangmany Cage said. “It’s a
commitment, not a hobby.”
Rick Hood, who served six years on the
Amherst School Committee, said he believes the talk about dysfunction is
overblown and not a good thing, though it only has minimal impact on
the day-to-day learning in the classroom.
He attributes the
dysfunction to people not talking to each other to clarify and resolve
issues, instead making assumptions that can inflame relationships.
Second,
Hood said there is what he calls an “invisible hand” that restrains
public debate in favor of support for the superintendent’s position.
“We
get into a vicious circle where restraint on debate causes an angry
response, which in turn clamps down more on debate, and creates more
angry response,” Hood said.
Having more sense of humor about even serious matters could reduce this tension, he said.
Jean
Fay, president of the Amherst-Pelham Education Association, said in an
email she is confident that Geryk’s departure, and the internal dynamics
on the school committee, will not have an impact on the schools,
observing that staff in all school buildings in Amherst and Pelham have
been working hard in recent weeks to prepare for the new school year.
“The
educators of the Amherst schools have always and will continue to be
focused on the students,” Fay said. “It’s who we are as educators.”
As
a special education para-educator, Fay said she is excited to start the
new school year and to make connections with her students that last
long after they graduate.
“I’m not sure if I can put into words
the joy that educators feel when we see our students grasp a concept, or
when they’re able to do a task all on their own for the first time,”
Fay said. “That’s what we’re focused on; everything else is just noise.”
Former Regional School Committee Chairman Lawrence O’Brien said
he observed disagreements during time on the board, which ended in March
2015, but not dysfunction.
“Certainly there were differences of
opinion and points of contention between members, but that is to be
expected on a democratically elected governing body that represents a
community with a diversity of opinion about our schools,” O’Brien said.
Like Hood and Fay, O’Brien said he is confident that high-quality instruction will continue in Amherst’s classrooms.
Previous issuesConcerns
about turmoil on the regional committee have existed for several years,
and the board held a retreat at Amherst College in August 2014 in which
it brought in a trained mediator.
Dolven, who was on the regional
committee at the retreat in 2014, expressed optimism at that time,
saying, “My hope is that starting today we can really figure out a way
to heal our committee, and hopefully the community can come together.”
An
earlier retreat was held in July 2010, moderated by the executive
directors of the Massachusetts Association of School Superintendents and
Massachusetts Association of School Committees in which the committee
discussed how to engage in conversations about how members behaved
toward each other and toward the administration.
At that time,
John Connolly, a representative from a consultant hired by the
committee, told the members that there was not a great response from
Massachusetts candidates during a search for a permanent superintendent
because of publicity about the “dysfunction” of the regional committee.
“A superintendent wants a School Committee that works together,” Connolly explained.
Hood
said having more time for retreats, including a representative from the
state association of school committees, could help members answer
questions and discuss how they should go about their work.
“The
retreats we have had in recent years were not long enough to do enough
good, and have only been annual,” Hood said. “At the last one I
attended, I felt like some really honest discussion was about to happen,
but then we ran out of time.”
Scott Merzbach can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com.
PVRS WE ARE WATCHING